Refutation, refutation, refutation! In the days and weeks that followed the Canberra conference, my paper didn't prompt any public comment. No-one on Hare's list of those "attacked" in its critique came out to dispute the case in The Australian. But privately, the first complaints had landed within hours. By the end of Day 3 in…
Diary of an academic infidel – Chapter 4
I woke up one day in early 2017, feeling terrible. Like Lucky Jim after a hard night's drinking. Picking up my phone, I used it to peruse the bruising. My face was a plausible match for the way my head felt. As if at some point during the night, I'd been beaten by secret police.…
Diary of an academic infidel – Chapter 3
Even with 2020 hindsight it's hard to explain exactly how the events of 2016 spiralled so far out of my sphere of control, and beyond my scope to influence. A media story in March drew ripples of umbrage and concern in Canberra, Melbourne and London. Which then morphed into a complaint. Which mutated into a…
Diary of an academic infidel – Chapter 2
In 2016 my career went bung at the University of Melbourne. The academic year began with a bang of bad publicity. And ended with a whimper of exhaustion and despair. Not the end of anyone's world, by any stretch. Trivial compared to your Trumps. A bagatelle compared to your Brexits. Infinitesimally piffling, compared to your…
Diary of an academic infidel – Chapter 1
Unemployed at last! Who can forget that feeling of freedom you get when, finally resigned, you clear your desk and walk out the door? Secure in the knowledge - or at least sustained by the hope - that (whoever's banishing whom) there is a world elsewhere? But that was then. Now it's 2020, and I'm…
Reforming Australian tertiary education: what did Clark Kerr do?
Back in November 2016, I posted a review of a new book about higher education in California in the 1960s. At the time it seemed relevant to Australia's own problems with growing demand for access, funding pressures and system-level reform. But the Australian tertiary system has not seen any comprehensive reform, then or since. So…
Debate quality in the university: how bad can it be?
Last month I looked at the uses and limits of academic freedom in Australia, taking the Peter Ridd affair at James Cook University as a case study. And also at how last year's French Review balanced two aspects of the work of universities: promoting free exchange as a way of exploring ideas, testing claims, exposing…
Let’s Glance: new OECD metrics on Australian tertiary spending
The 2020 edition of the OECD's Education at a Glance report landed on 8 September. In Australia it caused barely a ripple of public interest. With past editions, university sector press releases and media commentary usually appear within a few days. Typically, these highlight how low we look in the latest OECD "ranking" of tertiary…
Peter Ridd and the French Review connection
Good Riddance? Or Bad Judgments? The Peter Ridd versus James Cook University saga has been examined in two courts so far, in 2019 and 2020. Ridd's sea of troubles arose from complaints by another JCU professor (coral research centre director Terry Hughes) about his criticisms of Great Barrier Reef research. He was sanctioned in 2016…
Guest lecture notes on the 2020 higher education policy reform plan, Job Ready Graduates
Last week the University of Melbourne's Centre for Vocational and Educational Policy invited me to present on this topic to a group of 46 students, studying Education Policy and Reform. Presentation and discussion with Education Policy and Reform students. Image source: https://www.artofthetitle.com/title/game-of-thrones/ Our session was off-campus: a meeting of minds via Zoom, on a cool…
